They are springing up like mushrooms: wind turbines. A quick scan of various news websites reveals that many municipalities in the Netherlands are facing the installation of these turbines. Residents of Wijk bij Duurstede, Amsterdam (IJburg), and Deventer, among others, are seeing the turbines rising on the horizon.
These aren't small turbines, but gigantic structures reaching heights of over 200 meters. For comparison, the Euromast in Rotterdam is 185 meters tall. Sufficient reason for residents of such an area to be critical. Don't get me wrong, generating sustainable energy is a necessity, but I also see risks arising from placing large numbers of wind turbines close to residential areas.
Installing a wind turbine just a few hundred meters from homes results in noise pollution and shadow flicker for local residents. To prevent this, wind turbines are regularly shut down. However, this does not contribute to the much-needed sustainable energy generation. A stationary wind turbine is not only a blot on the landscape, but also a waste of the energy invested in its construction and the subsidies awarded.
Regional Energy Strategy vs. Common Interest
Part of the Climate Agreement requires each region to determine how and where sustainable electricity can be generated: choosing a regional approach over a national one is a good starting point. This approach is laid out in the Regional Energy Strategy (RES). Attention to detail, consideration of the interests of citizens and environmental organizations, leveraging local initiatives and customized solutions: it's all made possible by a regional approach. Sounds good!
Unfortunately, our shared interest in achieving climate goals, while considering everyone's interests, sometimes seems to be downgraded to a mere showpiece for local governments. Continuing to focus on specific solutions – without weighing interests, considering proposed alternatives, or taking citizens' concerns seriously – seems to be the norm. Residents' evenings are organized, where citizens rarely have a voice. Creating sufficient support is perceived by some local administrators as a burden. An alderman recently described this as the "wrong perceptions" of citizens that needed to be dispelled. This resented many residents. And rightly so! Why do residents have wrong perceptions? After all, they know very well what is and isn't locally feasible. Concerns about health risks don't just appear out of the blue; they are evident from literature and the adverse effects of wind turbines already installed in residential areas.

Not the benefits, but the burdens
Municipalities often state that residents' objections are visual pollution and shadow flicker. Personally, I hear other objections in my community and in the media as well. Of course, many find these turbines unattractive, but the concerns of local residents relate to health and the impact on local nature, not aesthetics. Most people are aware that sustainable energy is a necessity. I—and undoubtedly many others with me—are certainly willing to sacrifice residential comfort for the generation of sustainable energy. However, this must be compensated for. Local residents don't share in the revenue, but they do face the (excessive) nuisances.

Call: take objections seriously
Dear politicians, it's absurd that local residents have to unite, raise funds, and seek media attention to be heard. The current approach isn't a joint effort; it's a "politics/energy sector" team versus a "local residents" team. Don't treat residents' objections as something to be dismissed as quickly as possible; consider these objections seriously and realistically. Devise mitigating measures and investigate whether they will have a positive effect on the objection. Examples of measures include firm agreements on shutdown, moving the turbine 100 meters further away, subsidies for sound insulation, etc.
In short, engage in dialogue *with* each other and listen sincerely. From my professional perspective, you could approach this as risk management: every risk raised is taken seriously until proven otherwise or until the risk is accepted by all stakeholders. Negative health effects caused by low-frequency noise are often downplayed in order to proceed with the construction of wind turbines. Serious efforts must be made to work with local residents to develop appropriate measures to limit low-frequency noise and its consequences. Then it might even be possible that we all (partially) accept the consequences. After all, life is always a matter of give and take. That applies to residents *and* to politicians.
Melchert Rijks, Consultant



